Tuesday, July 8, 2025

What Bugs Me: Why Do We Call Him the Good Samaritan?

Calling this character the "good" Samaritan is not a choice that Jesus makes, it is the choice of the translators and the interpreters of the text.  However, it has become so ingrained in our understanding of these words of Jesus, that I have no doubt I will sow confusion by calling it the “Parable of the Priest, the Levite, and the Samaritan” in the previous post.

When Jesus tells the parable, he is building in a few expectations.  One is that the priest and the Levite (a temple worker) ought to be expected to be those who would tend to the beaten man.  But they pass by on the other side...was it leaving him for dead or leaving him to die?  I heard an attempt to rationalize their behavior in a sermon once.  They left him for dead because a dead body would make them ceremonially unclean and delay their temple duties.  The Law of Moses is pretty clear in this matter.  It would take a special ceremony and a certain number of days for them to become ritually clean once again, thus impacting their service in the House of the Lord.  Thus, this somehow justified their not checking on him, not getting 'involved'. 

But Jesus is not telling a parable about ceremonial cleanliness and uncleanliness.  He’s telling a parable about mercy and about neighbors.  The first demonstrating the proof of the second.  And these men, who lead in the worship and service of God, they both fail the test. 

This distinguishes them from the Samaritan who is a Good Neighbor (just like State Farm…can’t drown out the jingle) because he shows mercy.

But here’s what bugs me.  Jesus chose the Samaritan as the one who shows mercy because Samaritans are ‘no good’ in the religious understanding of the Jews of Judea and Samaria.  We caught a hint of that when James and John offered to bring down heaven-fire upon the Samaritan village back in Luke 9 (see posts from two weeks ago).  We also see it in the story of the Woman of Sychar, or the Woman at the Well, in John 4.

We are surprised that the Samaritan is the Good Guy because the expectation is that he is not good.  As we are surprised that the priest and the Levite are the Bad Guys, because the expectation is that they are not bad.

It bugs me how little progress we seem to have made on the understanding of ‘neighbor’.  We still have our “Samaritans”, people judged by something that makes them inherently bad except and until we can identify the ‘good’ ones.  But even more, that there are our “priests” and “Levites”, people judged by something that makes them inherently good except and until we can identify the ‘bad’ ones. 

And it really bugs me that I have just come around to one of the wisest sayings in the last century, “I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character.” 

I do not know what bugs me more, that it took me this long to come around to something I have heard from Martin Luthor King Jr. for most of my life, or that we have advanced so pitifully slow in making it reality.

pastor pete

No comments:

Post a Comment

In the Season of Advent, This Sunday is the Celebration of Joy

 Dear Fellow Church Members, Our passage for Sunday is Isaiah 35:   "The wilderness and the dry land shall be glad; the desert shall re...